Environmental claims: the EU rules and the records behind a claim
Since 27 September 2026, EU Member States have had to apply the national measures that transpose Directive (EU) 2024/825, known as the Empowering Consumers for the Green Transition Directive. It amends the Unfair Commercial Practices Directive (Directive 2005/29/EC), the EU's general law on how traders present products to consumers. Five practices were added to the list that is unfair in all circumstances, among them generic environmental claims that the trader cannot back with recognised excellent environmental performance, and claims that a product is neutral for the climate because emissions were offset. A sixth, about future performance such as a net zero date, is judged case by case. This page sets out what the text says, which records answer each provision, and which software categories in our catalogue hold those records. It covers claims made to consumers. It is general information, not legal advice, and it names no product.
Editorial responsibility: Dimitris Mitsios (Founder of The QHSE Standard; product marketing at Tekmon) · Tekmon pays for sponsored placements on this site (disclosure) · How pages are made · LinkedIn · Content date: 12 November 2026
On this page (13 sections)
What the Directive added on environmental claims
| Where it sits in Directive 2005/29/EC | The practice, as the text describes it | How it is assessed | The record that answers it |
|---|---|---|---|
| Annex I, point 2a | Displaying a sustainability label that is not based on a certification scheme or not established by public authorities | Unfair in all circumstances | The scheme's published terms, the certificate or licence, and evidence that a third party monitors compliance |
| Annex I, point 4a | Making a generic environmental claim for which the trader cannot demonstrate recognised excellent environmental performance relevant to the claim | Unfair in all circumstances | An EU Ecolabel licence, an officially recognised EN ISO 14024 type I ecolabel, or top performance under other Union law; or a specification of the claim on the same medium, which takes it out of the generic class |
| Annex I, point 4b | Making an environmental claim about the entire product or the trader's entire business when it concerns only a certain aspect or a specific activity | Unfair in all circumstances | A statement of scope: which part of the product, which sites and which period the data covers |
| Annex I, point 4c | Claiming, based on the offsetting of greenhouse gas emissions, that a product has a neutral, reduced or positive impact on the environment in terms of greenhouse gas emissions | Unfair in all circumstances | A life cycle assessment of the product showing that the claim rests on its own value chain; credit purchases recorded separately |
| Annex I, point 10a | Presenting requirements imposed by law on all products in the relevant category on the Union market as a distinctive feature of the offer | Unfair in all circumstances | The legal register entry showing who the requirement applies to |
| Article 6(2), point (d) | An environmental claim about future performance without clear, objective, publicly available and verifiable commitments in a detailed and realistic implementation plan, regularly verified by an independent third party expert whose findings are made available to consumers | Misleading action, case by case | The plan, its measurable and time-bound targets, the resources allocated, and each verification report with the place it is published |
| Article 6(2), point (e) | Advertising benefits to consumers that are irrelevant and do not result from any feature of the product or business | Misleading action, case by case | The basis for saying the benefit is specific to the product |
| Article 7(7) | For a service that compares products on environmental or social characteristics or circularity aspects: the method of comparison, the products and suppliers compared, and how the information is kept up to date count as material information | Misleading omission, case by case | The documented comparison method and its update routine |
How to read the two kinds of rule
The distinction in the third column matters more than any single row. Annex I to Directive 2005/29/EC is a list of commercial practices that are regarded as unfair in all circumstances: an authority does not have to show that a consumer was misled. Recital 2 of the 2024 Directive says the new Annex I points were added on that footing, while the changes to Articles 6 and 7 cover practices that are prohibited following a case-by-case assessment of whether they cause, or are likely to cause, the average consumer to take a transactional decision they would not otherwise have taken. A claim about a future net zero date falls in the second group, not the first. Publications Office of the EU: Directive (EU) 2024/825, Official Journal text of 6 March 2024; Publications Office of the EU: Directive 2005/29/EC, consolidated text of 27 September 2026
The Directive also added environmental and social characteristics, and circularity aspects such as durability, reparability and recyclability, to the main characteristics of a product about which a practice can mislead under Article 6(1), point (b). Annex I gained further points, 23d to 23j, on software updates, durability and repair. Those, and the changes to the Consumer Rights Directive on guarantee and repair information, are outside this page.
An environmental claim is defined widely. Under Article 2, point (o), as added, it is any message or representation that is not mandatory under Union or national law, in any form, including text, images, symbols, labels, brand names, company names and product names, made in a commercial communication, which states or implies that a product, product category, brand or trader has a positive or zero impact on the environment, is less damaging than others, or has improved over time. A generic claim is one that is not on a sustainability label and whose specification is not given in clear and prominent terms on the same medium. Recital 9 lists examples, among them ‘environmentally friendly’, ‘green’, ‘climate friendly’, ‘energy efficient’ and ‘biodegradable’, and contrasts ‘climate-friendly packaging’, which is generic, with a statement that 100 % of the energy used to produce the packaging comes from renewable sources, which is specific.
Who it covers: claims made to consumers
Directive 2005/29/EC applies to unfair business-to-consumer commercial practices before, during and after a commercial transaction in relation to a product (Article 3(1)), and a consumer is a natural person acting outside their trade, business, craft or profession (Article 2, point (a)). The 2024 Directive did not change that scope. The Commission services' Questions & Answers of September 2026 put it plainly: the Directive is limited to business-to-consumer practices and business-to-business practices fall outside it, although a Member State may extend the protection to businesses in its national law. So the first question for any claim is where it is made and to whom, and for a business-to-business seller the answer depends on the national law of each market. Publications Office of the EU: Directive 2005/29/EC, consolidated text of 27 September 2026; European Commission: Questions & Answers on Directive (EU) 2024/825, September 2026 (PDF)
The same document addresses sustainability reporting. It says that corporate sustainability reports, including disclosures required under the Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive, are typically not in scope, because they are often mandatory and addressed to investors; but that information from such a report used in voluntary advertising or marketing directed at consumers does fall under the rules. The Questions & Answers carry a disclaimer that they are preliminary views of the Commission services and not an official position, and that only the Court of Justice of the European Union can interpret EU law authoritatively. We cite them as the Commission services' reading, not as the law.
Carbon neutral, offsets and net zero dates
Point 4c is the provision most likely to affect wording already in use. Recital 12 says that offset-based claims that a good or service has a neutral, reduced or positive impact in terms of greenhouse gas emissions should be prohibited in all circumstances, and gives as examples ‘climate neutral’, ‘CO2 neutral certified’, ‘carbon positive’, ‘climate net zero’, ‘climate compensated’, ‘reduced climate impact’ and ‘limited CO2 footprint’. It adds that such claims should be allowed only when they are based on the actual lifecycle impact of the product, not on offsetting outside the product's value chain, and that the prohibition should not prevent companies from advertising their investments in environmental initiatives, including carbon credit projects, provided the information is not misleading. Publications Office of the EU: Directive (EU) 2024/825, Official Journal text of 6 March 2024
The Commission services' Questions & Answers add three readings worth knowing. A climate claim based on the product's own footprint across its value chain is outside point 4c, and would need to be substantiated through a proper life cycle assessment. Point 4c concerns products: it does not apply to offset-based claims made at company level, which remain subject to the other provisions of the Directive. And a bare ‘carbon neutral’ is also a generic environmental claim, so point 4a applies to it as well. European Commission: Questions & Answers on Directive (EU) 2024/825, September 2026 (PDF)
A statement about the future, such as a transition to climate neutrality by a stated year, is assessed under Article 6(2), point (d). Recital 4 describes what should stand behind it: commitments and targets set out in a detailed and realistic implementation plan that shows how they will be achieved and allocates resources, and verification by a third party expert who is independent of the trader, free from conflicts of interest, experienced and competent in environmental issues, and able to monitor progress regularly, with the findings available to consumers. The Directive sets no interval for that verification. The Questions & Answers say only that it is left to be determined in the circumstances, and suggest annual or biennial reviews as practice. For how a net zero target is defined in the first place, see our net zero glossary entry.
The records that substantiate a claim
A register of the claims themselves
Each claim as worded, where it appears (pack, website, advertisement, label), the markets it is shown in, its owner, and the evidence it relies on. Without it nobody can say which claims are generic, which concern the whole business and which rest on offsets.
The greenhouse gas inventory
For statements about the business: the boundary, the year, the activity data and the emission factors with their versions. A stated reduction has to be reproducible from these, and the boundary shows whether a claim describes the entire business or one activity.
Life cycle assessment or product footprint
For statements about a product: the study, its system boundary, the data period and who reviewed it. This is the record that separates a claim based on the product's own value chain from one based on offsetting.
Certification and ecolabel records
The licence or certificate, its scope and expiry, and the scheme's public terms. A certification scheme in the Directive's sense is open on fair terms, sets out how non-compliance is handled and is monitored by a competent, independent third party.
The implementation plan
For future performance: the commitments, measurable and time-bound targets, the resources allocated and the place the plan is published. The claim can point to it, for example on the trader's website.
The independent expert's findings
Each verification report, the expert's independence and competence, the date, and where consumers can read the findings. Keep the superseded reports as well as the current one.
Offset and credit purchases, kept apart
Project, registry reference, volume and retirement date, recorded separately from the footprint. A company may still talk about these investments if it does so without misleading; they cannot be the basis of a product neutrality claim.
The legal basis for anything presented as distinctive
A legal register entry showing whether a requirement applies to every product in the category on the Union market. If it does, presenting it as a feature of the offer falls under point 10a.
Why the record matters as much as the claim
The list above is ours: the Directive does not prescribe a set of documents. It follows from the provisions in the first table and from a rule that was already in Directive 2005/29/EC. Article 12 requires Member States to give courts or administrative authorities the power to require a trader to furnish evidence of the accuracy of factual claims made in a commercial practice, and to consider those claims inaccurate if the evidence is not furnished or is deemed insufficient. Point 4a is written the same way round: the practice is making a generic claim for which the trader is not able to demonstrate recognised excellent environmental performance. In both cases the trader has to be able to produce the evidence when asked, which in practice means it existed, and could be found, when the claim was published. Publications Office of the EU: Directive 2005/29/EC, consolidated text of 27 September 2026
That is a records problem before it is a marketing problem. The usual gap is not a missing study but a missing link: a claim on packaging that nobody can trace to a dated figure, a certificate that expired after the artwork was approved, a reduction figure calculated with factors that have since been replaced, or a group-wide statement resting on data from three sites out of twelve. Give each claim one owner, one evidence file and one review date, and keep superseded versions. The rules also reach products already on the market: the Questions & Answers say traders must ensure that claims and labels comply from 27 September 2026, including for stock manufactured or placed on shelves earlier, and mention covering or correcting a claim with a sticker, or adding information at the point of sale, as practical options. European Commission: Questions & Answers on Directive (EU) 2024/825, September 2026 (PDF)
Which software categories hold these records
No software category in our catalogue is defined as claim substantiation, and no product is presented here as making a claim compliant: whether a claim is lawful depends on its wording, the evidence and the national law that applies, not on the system that stores the file. What software can do is keep each record with its source, version, owner and date. The categories below are the ones whose published scope covers a record from the list above. Each link goes to a category or guide page, where products are listed under that page's published rule and in its order. We name and recommend none here.
Greenhouse gas inventory and product footprints
Activity data, emission factors and their versions, the boundary and the reporting year, so that a stated reduction can be recalculated.
Carbon accounting categoryCarbon accounting guideScope 3 emissions guide
Targets, the implementation plan and progress against it
The commitments, the measurable and time-bound targets, the owners and the reviewed figures that a statement about future performance refers to.
ESG and sustainability reporting categoryESG reporting guide
Site data behind a specific claim
Metered energy, renewable supply, waste and water records for the sites or product lines a claim covers, which is what shows whether it describes the whole business or one part of it.
Environmental data management categoryEnergy management guide
Certificates, licences, assessment reports and verification statements
The controlled copy of each document with its issuer, scope, version and expiry date, and the approval of the claim wording that relies on it.
Checks on claims and the findings of the independent expert
Internal reviews of published claims, the expert's findings and the actions raised from them, with dates and closure evidence.
Supplier declarations and certificates
Evidence collected from suppliers for claims about materials, recycled content or origin, with the period and the product it applies to.
The legal register
Which requirements apply to every product in a category, so that a legal minimum is not advertised as a distinctive feature, and which national measure transposes the Directive where you sell.
Regulatory compliance intelligence categoryRegulatory change guide
Life cycle assessment tools are not a category in our catalogue, so we link none; a study produced elsewhere is normally held as a controlled document. A spreadsheet can also be an adequate claims register for a small range. The test for any of these is the same one an authority would apply: starting from a published claim, can you reach the figure, the method, the source document and the person who approved it, as they stood on the day the claim went out? Our greenhouse gas inventory workbook is a free starting point for the inventory record.
Dates, enforcement and penalties
Article 4 of the 2024 Directive required Member States to adopt and publish their transposing measures by 27 March 2026 and to apply them from 27 September 2026. The Commission's page on the Unfair Commercial Practices Directive, read on 12 November 2026, states that the Directive entered into application on 27 September 2026 and links a consolidated text of that date. Because this is a directive, what binds a trader is the national measure in each Member State. The Commission services' Questions & Answers of September 2026 described transposition as still ongoing. On 12 November 2026 the EUR-Lex list of national transposition measures, read in a browser, showed 50 measures communicated by 23 of the 27 Member States and none from Spain, Malta, Portugal or Sweden. That list holds what Member States have notified; the page itself says it does not prejudge the Commission's check of whether a transposition is complete and correct, so a listed measure is not proof of full transposition. Publications Office of the EU: Directive (EU) 2024/825, Official Journal text of 6 March 2024; European Commission: Unfair Commercial Practices Directive; European Commission: Sustainable consumption; European Commission: Questions & Answers on Directive (EU) 2024/825, September 2026 (PDF)
Enforcement lies with national authorities and courts. Article 13 of Directive 2005/29/EC requires penalties that are effective, proportionate and dissuasive and leaves their level to each Member State. The figure of 4 % of turnover that is often quoted is narrower than it sounds: under Article 13(3) it is the minimum that the maximum fine must reach, measured on the trader's annual turnover in the Member State or States concerned, when penalties are imposed in a coordinated action under Article 21 of Regulation (EU) 2017/2394; where turnover information is not available, the maximum must be at least EUR 2 million. It applies across the whole Directive, not to environmental claims in particular, and it is not a description of national fines generally. Publications Office of the EU: Directive 2005/29/EC, consolidated text of 27 September 2026
Two dated notes: the United Kingdom and the Green Claims Directive
United Kingdom. UK consumer law is separate from the EU Directive. Part 4, Chapter 1 of the Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024 prohibits unfair commercial practices (section 225) and defines misleading actions (section 226); legislation.gov.uk shows both in force from 6 April 2025. Its list of practices that are unfair in all circumstances is Schedule 20, and on our reading on 12 November 2026 none of its paragraphs names environmental claims, sustainability labels or offsetting, so there is no UK counterpart to point 4c in that list and a green claim is assessed under the general provisions. Under Part 3, Chapter 4 the Competition and Markets Authority can enforce directly: a final infringement notice may carry a penalty of a fixed amount not exceeding £300,000 or, if higher, 10 % of the respondent's turnover (section 182), and the Authority may require evidence of the accuracy of a factual claim and determine the claim inaccurate if the evidence is not provided or is inadequate (section 195). The Authority's guidance on environmental claims, published on 20 September 2021 and known as the Green Claims Code, sets six principles, the last being that claims must be substantiated, and says businesses should hold robust, credible, relevant and up to date evidence. It states that it also applies, to a more limited extent, to businesses marketing to other businesses. legislation.gov.uk: Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024, Part 4, Chapter 1; legislation.gov.uk: Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024, Schedule 20; legislation.gov.uk: Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024, section 182; legislation.gov.uk: Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024, section 195; GOV.UK, Competition and Markets Authority: Making environmental claims on goods and services
Green Claims Directive. This is a separate proposal, not the Directive described above, and it is not law. The Commission proposed a directive on the substantiation and communication of explicit environmental claims on 22 March 2023 (COM(2023) 166, procedure 2023/0085(COD)). On 12 November 2026 the European Parliament's Legislative Observatory showed the procedure as ‘Awaiting Council's 1st reading position’. Its key events end with Parliament's first-reading decision of 12 March 2024, the committee decision of 4 December 2024 to open interinstitutional negotiations and its announcement in plenary on 16 December 2024; it lists no later procedural event and records no withdrawal. The Commission's own page showed the proposal's status as pending. Recital 13 of the 2024 Directive says only that additional requirements on environmental claims will have to be set in specific Union legal acts. Plan on the rules that apply now, and check the procedure file before relying on any report about the proposal. European Parliament Legislative Observatory: procedure 2023/0085(COD), Green Claims Directive; European Commission: Green claims
What we could not verify (12 November 2026)
- Whether any Member State has transposed the Directive completely and correctly, and the text of any national measure. We counted the entries on the EUR-Lex list of national transposition measures and opened none of the measures.
- The level of fines in any Member State, and any enforcement decision taken under the new provisions since 27 September 2026. We read none.
- The Common Understanding on existing stock that the Questions & Answers attribute to the national authorities of the Consumer Protection Cooperation Network. We did not open it.
- Whether the Competition and Markets Authority has revised its 2021 guidance for the 2024 Act. The page we read is dated 20 September 2021 and refers to the Consumer Protection from Unfair Trading Regulations 2008; the last part of that long page was not read.
- Any step on the Green Claims Directive proposal that the Legislative Observatory does not list, such as the state of negotiations between the institutions.
- We read the English texts. The Directive and the consolidated Directive 2005/29/EC were read in the Publications Office copies, because EUR-Lex returned no text to our reader; the consolidated text is a documentation tool without legal effect, as it says itself.
Questions to put to each claim
Sources and limits
12 sources, checked 12 Nov 2026
EU law: Publications Office of the EU: Directive (EU) 2024/825, Official Journal text of 6 March 2024; Publications Office of the EU: Directive 2005/29/EC, consolidated text of 27 September 2026. European Commission: European Commission: Unfair Commercial Practices Directive; European Commission: Sustainable consumption; European Commission: Questions & Answers on Directive (EU) 2024/825, September 2026 (PDF); European Commission: Green claims. European Parliament: European Parliament Legislative Observatory: procedure 2023/0085(COD), Green Claims Directive. United Kingdom: legislation.gov.uk: Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024, Part 4, Chapter 1; legislation.gov.uk: Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024, Schedule 20; legislation.gov.uk: Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024, section 182; legislation.gov.uk: Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024, section 195; GOV.UK, Competition and Markets Authority: Making environmental claims on goods and services. All read on 12 November 2026.
Nothing here is legal advice. We have summarised the operative text and quoted only short phrases; read the provisions, and the national measure that transposes them, before relying on this page. The record list and the mapping to software categories are our own reading of what each provision asks a trader to be able to show. They are not taken from the Directive and are not a compliance standard.
National law outside the EU and the United Kingdom, sector rules that take precedence over the general Directive (for example on organic production or energy labelling), advertising codes and the rules of individual certification schemes are not covered. No product was tested for this page and none is listed, ranked or recommended. We publish no figures on how many claims are affected or how often the rules are enforced, because we have not measured them and have read no official figure.
Related Guides
More related guides
- SBTi (Science Based Targets initiative) — definition, software & FAQs
Definition of the SBTi.
- Carbon Footprint Scenario Calculator — Your Quantities and Factors
Calculator for a Scope 1 and 2 carbon footprint.
- EU Taxonomy — definition, software & FAQs
Definition of the EU Taxonomy.
- Scope 3 Emissions in 2026: Data Strategy & Software Playbook
Article on Scope 3 emissions data.
- CSRD (Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive) — definition, software & FAQs
Definition of the CSRD.